Hawaii’s Low Rankings Highlight State Tax Competitiveness Challenges

a standard calculator, a metal pen, and several printed financial charts on a rustic wooden desk, with a potted tropical Monstera plant in the background, gentl

AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.

  • calendar_today November 17, 2026

Understanding State Tax Competitiveness

The national Tax Foundation releases an annual report ranking all 50 states and the District of Columbia on “state tax competitiveness.” Previously known as the states’ business tax climate study, this index considers not only how heavily a state taxes residents and businesses, but also evaluates the complexity and neutrality of each state’s tax structure. The report’s credibility is recognized within Hawaii, and the Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT) monitors these rankings in its State of Hawaii Data Book.

Hawaii’s Position in Tax Foundation Rankings

Hawaii consistently receives low grades in these rankings. According to the 2024 State of Hawaii Data Book and the Tax Foundation study, two main areas pull down Hawaii’s scores: the net income tax and state unemployment insurance (SUI) tax. While other factors contribute to the overall outcome, these two have the most significant negative impact on the state's business tax climate and competitiveness rankings.

The General Excise Tax: Not the Leading Concern

Contrary to some perceptions, the General Excise Tax (GET)—Hawaii’s broad sales tax equivalent—is not the foremost contributor to Hawaii’s low tax competitiveness. At a nominal rate of 4.5% (counting the county surcharge), the GET is lower compared to other states’ sales tax rates. Although tax pyramiding and business-to-business transactions can increase total tax paid, the GET’s nominal rate does not stand out as excessively high on the national spectrum.

Net Income Tax Complexity Drives Down Rankings

The net income tax is cited as a primary reason for Hawaii’s low tax competitiveness. Hawaii’s system is highly complex, featuring twelve separate tax brackets, including a newly established “millionaire’s bracket” from the recent legislative session. Extensive tax credits exist for lower-income taxpayers, adding to the system’s complexity. Many taxpayers may not fully understand or utilize these credits, further complicating compliance. The latest rankings place Hawaii at 42nd for tax competitiveness in 2025, reflecting recent (2024) tax cuts. However, as some cuts were partially reversed in 2025, the Tax Foundation warns Hawaii’s position will likely worsen in the next annual rankings.

State Unemployment Insurance: Persistent Underperformance

Hawaii’s state unemployment insurance is the second major drag on its rankings. In 2024, Hawaii placed 49th due to a relatively high SUI tax rate and one of the largest taxable wage bases nationwide. While most states levy SUI tax only on the first several thousand dollars of salary, Hawaii’s taxable wage base is unique—only Washington State taxes a higher wage base, and Hawaii stands alone in the $60,000–$70,000 range.

Future Outlook and Reform Considerations

For those interested in tax reform or improving Hawaii’s standing in state tax competitiveness, focusing on net income tax and the SUI tax system is essential. Addressing complexity and high wage bases may be key steps toward making Hawaii more competitive relative to other states.

Related coverage

Source: hawaiireporter.com.

Recent Posts

Google Ads

add ads here

Hot Categories