Hawaii’s Digital Shift Leads to Decline in Critical Tourism Data

a smartphone displaying a blank digital form resting on a wooden table next to a blank paper document and a cup of coffee, with a blurred background showing tro

AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.

  • calendar_today November 16, 2026

Participation in Hawaii's Tourism Survey Declines Sharply

Hawaii's transition from paper-based agricultural declaration forms to the digital Akamai Arrival system has resulted in a steep reduction in visitor survey participation. Previously, around 70% of travelers filled out the paper survey, but participation has dropped to about 23% on the digital platform, creating significant gaps in tourism data. These gaps have already led to the suspension of published visitor statistics for the islands of Molokai and Lanai.

Background: The Digital Transition and Its Effects

The decline began on March 1, 2025, when Hawaii's Department of Agriculture and Biosecurity digitized the state's mandatory agricultural declaration form. During this transition, tourism-related questions were temporarily removed and, despite being restored later, participation has not recovered. The new digital system requires travelers to complete the declaration before boarding their flights, and many either miss the link to the tourism survey or mistakenly believe it did not load correctly. As a result, daily survey responses have dropped from approximately 11,000 paper forms to about 3,800 digital submissions, of which only 1,400 are fully completed.

Consequences for Tourism Data Collection

Jennifer Chun, director of tourism research at the Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT), noted that while overall visitor arrival counts and expenditure trends remain reliable thanks to airline passenger counts and separate surveys, the depth of information on visitor characteristics has diminished. This results in a higher margin of error for data points about traveler intent, such as travel purpose or attendance at events and meetings. The lack of robust data complicates efforts by tourism agencies, policymakers, and businesses to track trends, plan for the future, and effectively allocate marketing resources.

Industry Concerns and the Importance of Reliable Data

The reduction in data is particularly significant for smaller islands. DBEDT suspended visitor statistics for Molokai and Lanai in February after it became impossible to accurately weight survey results. This is a concern for the visitor industry, especially in Lanai, which relies on tourism development and has a community-driven Destination Management Action Plan emphasizing the need for better engagement rather than reducing tourist numbers.

Economist Paul Brewbaker has called the data loss a "permanent gap year in economic time series continuity," criticizing the state for not consulting tourism stakeholders and failing to run parallel paper and digital systems during the transition. He also highlighted concerns about self-selection bias and the reliability of tourism metrics due to low participation in the digital survey.

Industry leaders including Keith Vieira of KV & Associates Hospitality Consulting, Aaron J. Sala of the Hawai‘i Visitors and Convention Bureau, and Jerry Gibson of the Hawai‘i Hotel Alliance echoed these concerns. They emphasized that while data from credit card companies, airlines, and hotels is valuable, it does not provide a complete picture and cannot substitute for direct visitor surveys. Detailed survey data is essential for decisions about marketing, product development, hotel operations, and investments.

Efforts and Proposals to Boost Survey Participation

State officials are exploring solutions to increase participation in the digital tourism survey. Suggestions include improving the digital interface between the Akamai Arrival declaration and the tourism survey, offering incentives such as coupons and promotions to visitors who complete the survey, and possibly collecting more data directly from industry partners. State Sen. Glenn Wakai, a proponent of digitization, acknowledged the drop in response rates but maintained that a 23% completion rate is statistically meaningful. Still, he suggested incentivizing participation rather than making it mandatory.

Vieira and others recommended making the process more convenient or offering perks, while Gibson proposed contracting professional firms to gather and aggregate tourism data from various sources to supplement direct surveys.

Ongoing Debate and Next Steps for Hawaii's Tourism Data Collection

As tourism leaders and policymakers discuss solutions, concerns remain about the effect of reduced marketing, weakening tourism data, and slower demand, especially for smaller islands and local businesses. Accurate visitor survey information is still seen as essential for measuring traveler behavior and guiding industry strategy. Efforts to revamp Hawaii's digital tourism data collection continue, as stakeholders seek to restore the state's longstanding advantage in tourism market insights.

Source: westhawaiitoday.com.

Recent Posts

Google Ads

add ads here

Hot Categories